Honestly idk what to say….i was quite confused why this repetition kept occurring even when the book ended…like it did not add much to why SHE had to experience all that??? Also the thing with Josh….i did not understand that too. And he deserved to be more mad/upset over what she did than just a “i had it coming” (he did not. not that day in the timeloop anyway. she does not like assumptions but she went ahead and assumed what happened that day. so nope not a fan.) Overall, not my fav and would have loved to see some character growth in Emilie.