
Follow friends on the app and stay updated!
Scan the QR code

Follow friends on the app and stay updated!
Scan the QR code

Recent

SKY Castle
Movie / TV
first of all OHHHH the male actors’ performances in this was horrific!!! in the original i HATED the characters, but in this one i was laughing at them because umm yall sound ridiculous and cartoon villainesque. also it’s been a very hot minute since i watched the original but it’s one of my favourite dramas ever so i might be biased but i think this jpn version is so far removed from the original. the core points—wealth disparity leading to a more pronounced inequity in education, the questioning of an increasingly pressure cooker-like environment for test-taking children, parents’ role in aiding this rat race, the questioning of whether there is actual social mobility upwards—were totally lost in the weird pace and terrible dialogue of this version. i think the fact that they kept the title SKY Castle, with SKY referring to the top 3 universities in South Korea (Seoul, Korea, Yonsei) was also a bit of a dud. that reference is lost, even more so when the kids are aged down to be middle schoolers who aren’t even close to taking their uni entrance exams yet. on that note about middle schoolers- WTF AT HARUTO HAVING A CHILD WITH THE HOUSEKEEPER? his mum totally had a valid reason to be upset at this but we’re supposed to sympathise with the housekeeper because she told his mum not to pressure him to study so hard??? GIRL SHE ALSO COMMITTED STATUTORY RAPE!! we should be taking that a tad more seriously especially in a series about the welfare of children, don’t you think?? honestly i think this was a bit of a ham-fisted adaptation. the original is 1000x times better and adept at commenting on the social issues plaguing children today. this one just shouted at us “we are talking about isses x, y, and z!!” (like, the scene of the wives introducing izumi as a writer and listing her works 😭😭) without actually ever making the audience ponder the question, while the original showed more than told.
0
0
3
0